Multi-Carrier Shipping: Combining Several Parcel Carriers from One German Warehouse

Multi-carrier shipping uses several parcel carriers in parallel and picks the best one per shipment. Benefits, shipping rules in the WMS and when it pays off.

πŸ”€
Multi-Carrier Shipping β€” in brief

Multi-carrier shipping means a warehouse connects several parcel carriers (for example DHL, DPD, GLS and UPS) in parallel and assigns each shipment to the most suitable one by rule: weight, dimensions, destination country, transit time and price. This lowers shipping costs and removes dependence on a single carrier.

What is multi-carrier shipping?

Multi-carrier shipping is a shipping strategy in which a warehouse works with several carriers in parallel instead of one. Rather than handing all parcels to a single parcel service, a set of rules decides for each shipment which carrier and which shipping product is used. The opposite is single-carrier shipping with one contract and one rate card.

The term should not be confused with shipping platforms such as Sendcloud. They simplify access to many carriers through one integration but are not carriers themselves. Multi-carrier shipping describes the strategy; the platform is one of the possible tools for it.

The German parcel market in brief

Sellers coming from the UK or overseas often assume one national carrier covers everything. In Germany four networks matter for e-commerce parcels. DHL is the largest consumer network and the only one that serves Packstation parcel lockers, which many German shoppers prefer. DPD and GLS are strong in business deliveries and have dense networks in neighbouring EU countries. UPS is typically chosen for express and time-definite services. Each has different size limits, surcharges and strengths, which is exactly why mixing them pays off.

How multi-carrier shipping works in practice

The core is the shipping rule set in the warehouse management system (WMS). Each rule checks attributes of the order and assigns carrier and product. A typical rule set for a shop shipping from Germany looks like this:

  1. Small parcel up to 1 kg, domestic: cheapest small-parcel product, often with reduced tracking.
  2. Standard parcel up to 31.5 kg, domestic: main carrier; if the customer chooses a Packstation, DHL is mandatory.
  3. Girth over 300 cm or length over 120 cm: carrier with a higher limit, to avoid bulky-goods surcharges.
  4. Destination Austria, Benelux, France: carrier with its own network in the destination country, see cross-border fulfillment.
  5. Express chosen at checkout: UPS or DHL Express with a delivery guarantee.
  6. Fallback: if one carrier's interface fails, the next one takes over automatically.

After assignment, the WMS creates the shipping label through the relevant carrier interface, prints it at the packing station and reports the tracking number and carrier back to shop and customer. For the customer the process stays the same; only the delivery driver differs.

CriterionSingle carrierMulti-carrier
Shipping costsone rate card for all shipmentscheapest suitable rate per shipment
Resiliencea strike or outage hits 100 % of shipmentsrerouting to the second carrier
Bulky and special formatssurcharges of the one carriercarrier with a matching limit
International shippingoften expensive and slowspecialised carrier per destination country
Peak seasoncapacity cap of one providervolume spread across several networks
Effortlowrule set and integrations required

Why multi-carrier shipping matters for online sellers

Postage is the largest block within shipping costs, and shipping is a major part of overall fulfillment costs. Sending each shipment with the cheapest suitable carrier typically saves 5 to 15 % of postage. At 2,000 parcels a month and an average postage of €5, that is €6,000 to €18,000 a year. For orientation, a DHL domestic parcel in Germany costs €3.99 to €6.50 net on typical business rates. Resilience in the fourth quarter comes on top: when one carrier imposes intake stops during peak season, parcels keep moving through the other networks.

The customer side benefits as well. Some recipients want delivery to a Packstation, others to the parcel shop around the corner, and customers in B2B fulfillment need delivery before noon. One carrier covers only part of that. Note that each carrier has its own collection time, so the cut-off time for same-day shipping can differ by carrier.

!
Common mistake

Multi-carrier without a rule set. When packers choose the carrier by gut feeling, the result is wrong bookings, wrong products and unnecessary surcharges. The decision belongs in the WMS, not on the packing table.

βœ“
Practical tip

Map the shipping methods in your shop to carrier products before go-live. "Standard", "Express" and "Parcel locker" at checkout must each translate into a clear rule. This mapping is a fixed item in every fulfillment onboarding.

How LogYou handles it

LogYou ships with DHL, GLS, UPS and DPD as well as through Sendcloud. The rules run in its own platform LogShip, and shipment status is visible live in the client portal. Details are on the shipping page.

Frequently asked questions about Multi-Carrier Shipping

What is the advantage of multi-carrier shipping?
Every shipment travels with the carrier that offers the best price and transit time for its weight, dimensions and destination country. That typically saves 5 to 15 per cent of postage costs. In addition, shipping keeps running during strikes, capacity bottlenecks or system outages at one carrier.
From what volume does multi-carrier shipping pay off?
For a single shop, a second carrier contract of its own usually only pays off from a few hundred parcels a month, because every contract brings minimum volumes and maintenance. Through a fulfillment provider you use the carrier mix from the first parcel, because the provider bundles the contracts.
Do I need special software for multi-carrier shipping?
Yes, a WMS or shipping software with a rule engine and carrier integrations. The software has to decide automatically per order which carrier and product to use, create the label and report the tracking number back to the shop. Manual selection at the packing station only works for very small volumes.
Author

Natascha Deneke Β· Operations & Warehouse

Responsible for operations and the warehouse at LogYou β€” from goods receipt and pick & pack to returns handling.

Questions about Multi-Carrier Shipping for your shop?

We have been shipping parcels for e-commerce brands every day since 2014. Tell us your parcels per day and shop system β€” we reply with a concrete assessment.

Related services

Questions left?

Talk directly to the people who will run your warehouse β€” no call center, no queue.

Reply within 24 h Β· Mon–Fri 9–16 h by phone too
FreeReply within 24 h